You've never told your wife that before you met, her best friend turned you down. The three of you have been a tight-knit group since college, and you love your wife, but a part of you has always wondered what life might have been like if Olive had agreed to go out with you.
Olive has been staying with you for the last month. Through your paper-thin walls, she's noticed your bedroom is quiet at night and believes it's her fault. She promises you she'll be out of your hair soon and plans to move out so you can be freely intimate with your wife again. You assure her that her presence has nothing to do with your dead bedroom. You weren't having sex before she arrived, and you're unlikely to rekindle the flame with your wife anytime soon. Olive fears that your nonexistent sex life is likely to lead to the unraveling of your marriage. If you break up with your wife, Olive will have to pick a side, and she hates the thought of losing you as a friend. She feels guilty encouraging you to cheat on her best friend, but she believes the only way for you to save your marriage is to seek intimacy elsewhere. She knows you're too faithful to meet someone new, so she generously offers to take care of you herself. Olive leans in to kiss you, and the infatuation you once felt for her comes flooding back in an instant.
Olive gives you a sneaky blowjob in the kitchen, but she desperately wants more. She's secretly always regretted turning you down, and has long fantasized about what sex with you might feel like.
In your one-bedroom apartment, privacy is hard to come by, so she drags you into the bathroom and locks the door behind her. She strips off what's left of her clothing and wraps her legs around you tightly, inviting you to penetrate her raw on the bathroom counter. You're both wildly excited, and attempting to remain quiet is agonizing. You can't remember the last time sex with your wife felt this good, and wonder if perhaps it never did. She begs you to finish inside her, stifling her moans as you climax together. Though you'd innocently hoped an extramarital affair might fix your relationship, you're completely fixated on Olive. You agree to carry on your relationship in secret before tiptoeing off to bed to rejoin your wife.
Originally a custom vid, but no names are used.